Crisis Response Models as an Alternative to Traditional Behavioral Health Care

Written By: Molly Wilkinson

Date: November 21, 2026

Photo by Henry Lind on Unsplash

My brother has a dual diagnosis and has cycled through homelessness, hospitalization, and treatment programs for the past nine years. Growing up in San Francisco, I watched public health interventions unfold not as policy, but as moments: some handled with care and dignity, others undermined by systems not built to hold complexity. San Francisco’s Street Crisis Response Team, which has since been disbanded, was one of the first times I saw what non-judgmental, experience-informed care could look like, and how differently my brother responded to it. I also witnessed the limits of crisis intervention: when care ends at stabilization, when eligibility thresholds determine who's sick enough to receive help, when services exist but aren't accessible to the people who need them most.

When someone experiences a behavioral health crisis, having access to the right support can make all the difference in their recovery. Too often, people experiencing these crises find themselves navigating systems that are fragmented, difficult to access, and often poorly equipped to address their needs. Many end up in emergency rooms, hospitals, or jails rather than receiving support from trained mental health professionals. The experiences of those working in and navigating these systems reveal both what experience-informed care could look like, and where crisis intervention systems fail the people they’re meant to serve. 

Overreliance on and Limitations of Traditional Crisis Response

Traditional behavioral health care relies on emergency departments, hospitalization, and law enforcement as primary responders, which are not always equipped to address the needs of someone experiencing a mental health crisis. 

Hospitalization 

Frequently used as a default response when timely outpatient and community-based alternatives aren’t available, hospitalization often results in prolonged stays, financial burden, and gaps in ongoing care. Studies show that average hospital stays for people experiencing mental health issues are longer than the general patient population. In Missouri, hospital stays for schizophrenia were longer than those for several major physical health conditions, including kidney transplants or hip replacement surgeries. These extended stays contributed to significant healthcare expenditures. In 2014, total hospital charges of hospitalizations for serious mental illness exceeded half a billion dollars in the state of Missouri. 

Additionally, inpatient treatment doesn’t always guarantee that a person will receive consistent support after discharge. Many individuals struggle to connect with and transition into outpatient and community services, noting several barriers like limited transportation, housing instability, and poor communication between disconnected providers. For families, this can mean repeatedly navigating a system that provides temporary intervention without always offering a clear path forward. Getting someone through a crisis is paramount, but what happens once they leave the hospital matters just as much.

Emergency Departments 

Emergency departments (EDs) are also not equipped to properly support people experiencing mental health crises. One example is psychiatric boarding, which occurs when patients experience extended wait times while waiting for an inpatient psychiatric bed to become available. Although bed shortages are a major contributor to these delays, they can also reflect broader structural problems within the mental health care system, including a lack of funding for alternative facilities and programs, insurance barriers, and limited transportation to and from said facilities. During these extended waits, patients may receive little or no specialized behavioral health care. Staffing shortages can further limit the support available to patients while they await admission. 

Law Enforcement

Beyond hospitals and emergency departments, law enforcement is also frequently relied upon to respond to behavioral health crises. Police officers are often sent to manage these emergencies despite not necessarily having the training or resources to provide appropriate mental health care. These encounters raise concerns about the violence, criminalization, and stigmatization associated with police-led responses. People with mental illnesses face a higher risk of forceful, and even fatal, encounters with police. In fact, nearly ¼ of fatal police shootings from 2015 to 2021 involve people with mental illnesses. These risks are also shaped by race, with Black people nearly three times more likely to be fatally shot by police than white people. Beyond fatal encounters, people with mental illnesses are also overrepresented in jails. In Missouri, roughly 28% of people in state prisons are diagnosed with a serious mental illness. These statistics represent more than a problem with how emergency calls are handled. They reflect the consequences of treating behavioral health crises primarily as emergencies to control rather than experiences that require understanding and care. This raises an important question: What would crisis response look like if mental health professionals were the primary responders? 

Community-Based Alternatives

Given the limitations of traditional crisis response systems, some communities are implementing alternative community-based models that supplement or police involvement or remove it entirely. The Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration (SAMHSA) 2025 National Crisis Guidelines recommend prioritizing mobile crisis teams staffed by trained behavioral health professionals who bring support directly to those in crisis. The guidelines also advocate for providing peer support by including people with lived experience on these teams. 

These teams can take different forms depending on the needs and resources of a community. One model is Behavioral Health Practitioner-Only (BHP-only), which relies exclusively on licensed practitioners and peer support workers to de-escalate the crisis, clinically assess individuals, and connect them with ongoing care. Another model is co-response, which integrates law enforcement or other first responders with mental health professionals, allowing the latter to contribute specialized knowledge and support. Although these models differ in their staffing and approach, they share common goals: diversion from emergency and law enforcement services, de-escalation, and connection to ongoing care. 

The distinction between these approaches is important. A person experiencing a mental health crisis is not simply a problem that needs to be managed. They are someone with a history, relationships, fears, and needs that may not be immediately visible. Community-based models create opportunities to respond to those needs more directly. My family's experience with San Francisco's Street Crisis Response Team gave me a glimpse of what that difference can look like

What Do These Models Accomplish?

Reduced Hospitalization and Emergency Service Use

Crisis response models tend to reduce psychiatric hospitalizations and emergency department visits. One study found that youths who received mobile crisis services were much less likely to return to emergency departments and had fewer overall visits compared to those who had received care in the emergency department alone. Similarly, a comparative study of three community-based models—office-based, mobile crisis and co-response— found that mobile and office-based models were significantly more likely to avoid hospitalization by resolving crises on-site than models involving law enforcement.

Diversion from Law Enforcement

Crisis response models have also been shown to reduce reliance on law enforcement by diverting nonviolent calls and resolving crises without police involvement. For example, Oregon’s Crisis Assistance Helping Out on the Streets (CAHOOTS) program, which operates alongside police and fire services through a shared dispatch system, is estimated to divert 5-8% of calls that would otherwise go to law enforcement. The program operates largely independently, requesting police backup in only 2% of overall cases, although this percentage is higher in more severe cases. Inspired by the CAHOOTS approach, Denver’s Supported Team Assisted Response (STAR) program shows similar success; in its first six months it diverted roughly 3% of 911 calls from law enforcement. 

Connection to Ongoing Support

In addition to reducing reliance on emergency services and law enforcement, community-based crisis response models can strengthen follow-up support and connect people with needed resources. Research cited by SAMHSA suggests that mobile crisis services can improve connections to outpatient care through coordination and referrals. A comparative study also found that mobile services were more likely to provide people with resources and follow-up care than co-response teams or law enforcement-only models.

Reduced Intervention Costs

Finally, research cited by SAMHSA suggests that mobile crisis response can lower the cost of intervention. One study found that mobile services lowered the average cost per case by 23% compared to traditional law enforcement intervention, and another found that these services can reduce inpatient hospitalization costs by 79% during the six months following a crisis.

When I think about my brother, I don’t think first about hospital stays, treatment programs, or statistics. I think about the person who dances unabashedly to his favorite music, who finds joy in connecting with older folks, and who has so much more to offer than the hand he was dealt.

The research shows that community-based crisis response models offer a promising alternative to traditional approaches to behavioral health care. From reducing ED visits and diverting calls from law enforcement to improving connections with ongoing support, these programs and teams demonstrate that people experiencing mental health crises can receive care outside of hospitals and the criminal justice system. As communities look for better ways to respond to these emergencies, prioritizing care from trained mental health professionals can help create a system that ensures people like my brother receive the support, dignity, and continued care they deserve.   

Written by: Molly Wilkinson

About the author: Molly (she/her) is an editorial intern at NB

Crisis Intervention, Behavioral Health Care, Mental Health Care

Check out our social media for more resources:

Instagram
Facebook
BlueSky
Tumblr
Tiktok
Pinterest

Additional Reading

← Back To Lemon-Aid